The Latest on The Old Town Hall Property

    9
    7

    It’s been sitting untouched for close to a year now after the town made a big announcement that it would be converting the old town hall property to an 80-spot paid parking lot with discounts for town workers. Residents on Tropical Shores Way want answers to why the lot is still a mess.

    Tropical Shores Way resident Kathleen Greff wrote an e-mail to the town council after not receiving an adequate answer from the Mayor on the Sunday show when we asked about it. Here’s the letter she wrote followed by the Town Manager’s reply.

    Dear members of the town council,

    I would like to bring up the subject of the former town hall property. What is going on here? Week after week, I email Ed Ryan to ask the Mayor on Sundays, and the answers keep getting vaguer. Just this morning we heard: “It’s status quo,” “It’s not been determined what the best use of that property is,” “Maybe some sort of private/public property,” “It’s to be determined later.”

    Determined later? It has been FOUR YEARS. I am embarrassed when friends and family come to visit, and this is the turn-off onto my street. They ask what they are doing with the land, and I have to respond, “nothing yet.” I have been a huge supporter of this council since Ian, but it is wearing thin. I cleaned up my property; how about you clean up yours?
    Respectfully, 
    Kathie Greff

     

    Ms Greff:

    Thank you for writing, and for asking a direct question. You deserve a direct answer.

    You’re right that four years is too long for public land at the entrance to your street to look the way it does. You cleaned up your property after Ian. The Town should meet the same standard, and I hold myself to it.

    When staff first recommended turning the site into a paid public parking lot, it looked simple. It wasn’t. Paid parking turned out not to be an authorized use of that land. A project of that size also needs the same survey, zoning review, site plan, stormwater design and landscaping we require of every private property owner on this island. The early work was moving ahead without all of that, so I stopped it. The Town cannot hold residents and builders to one standard and itself to another, and I was not willing to keep spending taxpayer dollars on a project that wasn’t compliant.

    That pause cost time. It was the right decision, and I’d make it again. I also know it doesn’t change what your guests see when they turn onto Tropical Shore Way.

    What the site finally becomes, whether a parking lot, a public-private partnership or something else, is for Town Council to decide in a public meeting. Staff’s job right now is the groundwork any use will require: the survey, zoning, site constraints, and stormwater drainage, which matters to every home on your street. When the Mayor says, “to be determined,” what I hear him saying is that Council should decide with real facts and real costs in front of it, not assumptions.

    There is also a funding reality. This project has no dedicated funding. Before we build anything there, we must identify the money properly and responsibly, and I won’t take it from higher-priority projects the island is still depending on. That takes longer than any of us would like, but it is how we protect every taxpayer’s dollar.

    From where you sit, though, that work is invisible, and it sounds like nothing is happening. We should explain it better, and that’s on us.

    In the meantime, I will ensure that the site is mowed, cleared of debris, and kept presentable while the longer-term work continues.

    You’ve supported this us since Ian, and you know that corner better than anyone at Town Hall. I want it to become something you’re proud to point out to family. If you’d ever like to talk more about the site or share your ideas for it, I’d welcome the conversation.

    Respectfully,
    Will

    Dependable, Accurate, Investigative Journalism take time. To support our work, become a BTR Monthly Member HERE.

    9 COMMENTS

    1. A parking lot that close to the Fire Department? That sounds very dangerous to me. 2 lane road, traffic during season ? I would feel very sorry for anyone with an emergency requiring help!

      • Sorry, no, it was not zoned entirely commercial until the recent purchase for the food truck park. Prior it was zoned “partially” commercial and remainder residential.
        Check it out for yourself!

    2. Seems only fair that the City would live by example. O have not driven that way in a while so couldn’t say if the actual building was demolished and the lot clear up of any debris.
      I can tell you that next to my property there is a corner house that is empty since Ian
      a two story duplex, don’t know exactly the true story about it from the owner (since I have heard different ones) but I bought a bucket of rat poison and gave it to the neighbor accross the street to place in the house and neighboring houses (away from cats & dogs) and in a matter of one week he collected over (35) dead rats that were tuning around in the neighborhood.

    3. Boy…. What an inflated lame response. And the only reason why it was given was because the concern was brought to a public forum. In other words, nothing is going to happen anytime soon. No plan or financing for the lot. Who made the decision in the first place to start the project? This is just another example of poor management and lack of transparency.

    4. Dear Will and Council,
      Whatever the decision is for the old Town Hall property, please, please give some consideration to any additional traffic that it might create on that corner. The additional impact on that corner would also reach across the street with the now impending food truck court traffic, both cars and foot traffic, to drastically effect the RESIDENTS in a formerly residential neighborhood. Not all development is necessarily conducive to safety, comfort or added value for the residents that live nearby who may struggle for access to Estero. It is also a matter of safety and security for our properties.

      Carolyn McKeown

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here