Vacation Rentals In The Crosshairs


This is something a lot of people will want to keep an eye on. It’s an issue that will impact many of you both on Fort Myers Beach and Sanibel. There are several bills creeping through the Senate and House in Tallahassee that will give the state more control over how vacation rentals are regulated.

The state wants to require online platforms such as Airbnb to pay a tax on vacation rental properties so that only licensed rentals are advertised. Those paying that tax will have to provide the state with specific information about the rentals. In turn, the state would be in charge of regulating the rentals, taking that responsibility away from local governments such as the Town of Fort Myers Beach and Sanibel. On Fort Myers Beach now, vacation rental homes are everywhere, mixing in with year-round residents, in nearly every residential neighborhood.

The new state law would only allow local governments to regulate the rentals the same way they would any other property in neighborhoods. Local governments say they need to be able to regulate vacation rentals differently to prevent party houses, mini-hotels and commercial operations in residential neighborhoods.

Some lawmakers believe when people buy these homes they should be able to operate them as they see fit. In some cases, they’re investments that provide them with income during their retirement years. And, some homeowners agree that they are entitled to the same rights as their neighbors and shouldn’t be regulated differently.

If the state does end up regulating vacation rentals it would fall under the Division of Hotels and Restaurants.

The proposed bill would do away with ordinances regulating short-term rentals adopted after June 1, 2011, so the town council on Fort Myers Beach is being patient, making sure not to monkey with its own ordinances that may have been approved before 2011, which would grandfather them in.

Here are two bills to keep an eye on:
Senate Bill 522
House Bill 219

Sanibel Vice Mayor Holly Smith is spearheading the effort on behalf of the Sanibel City Council to write a letter to send to lawmakers to voice their concerns with this legislation. She’s called Fort Myers Beach Vice Mayor Rexann Hosafros asking the Fort Myers Beach town council to do the same, which they plan to do.

We have put a request in to have Representative Adam Botana on our show next Saturday to discuss this issue. He’s responded that he will confirm yes or no this Monday.




    Was it not just over a year ago, the rental industry crowding into FMB’s town council meeting room trying to stop the latest ordinance from the town’s council putting more government onto the local rental industry? The State is doing the same thing to the town and look who is writing letters now! Government on top of government controlling the smallest of businesses. What goes around, comes around. We did not need more regulations then, and we don’t need them now.

  2. Not sure how I feel about state wide regulations. Would a place like FMB become a free for all, where ALL homes, regardless of zoning can be rented out as short term rentals?

  3. There was an interesting article in the Wall Street Journal last fall about towns like Sedona Arizona being so bought up by Air B&B type of rentals that whole neighborhoods changed and so many families left that an elementary school was closed in that town. I do think we who are residence here need to watch what the state might allow to happen here .

Comments are closed.